- Health supplements
- Amazon US
- Listing optimization and Sponsored Products
- November 2024–January 2025
8x the sales in one month, by fixing the listing and the ads together
By testing Paragon’s listing content alongside its advertising, we lifted ad sales 8.3x from December to January and cut ACOS from 78% to 27%. In the final 10 days before stock ran out, ACOS was 17%.
- Ad sales
- 8.3x
- December → January
- Ad orders
- 11x
- December → January
- ACOS, Jan’s final 10 days
- 17%
- down from 78%
01 · Before
The situation
Paragon is a family-owned, USA-made supplement brand. Its first product is an immune-support formula, which we launched on Amazon in fall 2024.
Two months in, the ads were reaching people but not persuading them. In December, Paragon’s ads were shown widely, yet only 0.13% of shoppers clicked, and just 1 in 32 of those bought. ACOS sat at 78%, after 80% in November. Every dollar of ad spend brought back $1.29, barely more than it cost.
02 · Turning point
Three decisions
- 01
Treated the listing as part of the ad
We ran a series of listing content experiments and judged each one by what it did to click-through and conversion.
- 02
Moved content and ads in step
Each content change was paired with advertising changes, so every test got enough traffic to read quickly, and winning versions got the budget.
- 03
Traded reach for relevance
Impressions fell 86% while clicks rose 4.4x, as ads concentrated on the shoppers most likely to buy. Cost per click fell 68% between November and January.
03 · After
The full numbers
In January, ad sales rose 8.3x on December, on 2.9x the spend. Ad orders rose 11x, and ACOS fell from 78% to 27% for the month.
The improvement kept compounding. In January’s final 10 days, ACOS was 17.3%, 1 in 10 clicks became an order, and those 10 days alone produced two-thirds of the month’s ad sales. Then inventory ran out with momentum at its peak.
| Sponsored Products | Nov 2024 | Dec 2024 | Jan 2025 | Jan 22–31, 2025 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| ACOS | 80.3% | 77.7% | 26.9% | 17.3% |
| Return per $1 of ad spend | $1.25 | $1.29 | $3.71 | $5.78 |
| Click-through rate | 0.24% | 0.13% | 4.08% | 7.76% |
| Ad conversion rate | 5.56% | 3.17% | 7.95% | 10.50% |
ACOS
- Nov 2024
- 80.3%
- Dec 2024
- 77.7%
- Jan 2025
- 26.9%
- Jan 22–31, 2025
- 17.3%
Return per $1 of ad spend
- Nov 2024
- $1.25
- Dec 2024
- $1.29
- Jan 2025
- $3.71
- Jan 22–31, 2025
- $5.78
Click-through rate
- Nov 2024
- 0.24%
- Dec 2024
- 0.13%
- Jan 2025
- 4.08%
- Jan 22–31, 2025
- 7.76%
Ad conversion rate
- Nov 2024
- 5.56%
- Dec 2024
- 3.17%
- Jan 2025
- 7.95%
- Jan 22–31, 2025
- 10.50%
04 · The lesson
Fix both halves of the sale
Ads can only amplify what a listing already does. When shoppers scroll past a listing, more budget just buys more ignored impressions. Testing the content and the ads together fixed both halves of the sale at once: the reason to click, and the reason to buy. Once the listing converted, every ad dollar worked harder.